If you spend any time in the breastfeeding trenches of the internet you’ll come across a few phrases used again and again.
Own your decision:
I hate that saying by amateur lactivists. As if the point where you, determined to breastfeed, desperately start using formula feels anything like a choice, let alone one you supposedly need to ‘own up to’ (like you are guilty) and take responsibility for. I’ve found most people who feel a sense of relief at stopping breastfeeding are not shy about sharing, but ‘own your decision’ is most often said to those who are, for some bizarre reason, seen to be making excuses. Those who chose to feed their babies and not suffer. I don’t know how ‘my baby was losing too much weight’, ‘latching was agonizing (and there was no help)’, or ‘I couldn’t get out enough with a pump’, and so on are excuses. Explanations, yes. Excuses no. That would imply that something wrong was being done, as opposed to explaining why this situation you’ve found yourself in isn’t going the way you’d like.
Nearly all (or some numerical variation thereof) women can breastfeed:
I hate this one so much I devoted an entire post to it. It’s a phrase designed to imbue confidence and empower women, which is fine, but it ends up used as a shaming device, which is not fine. It’s vague and imprecise and unhelpful. Unhelpful because people are told that ‘statistic’ and thus never become aware of the signs and symptoms of what ‘unable to breast feed’ looks like.
Happy mummy=happy baby:
What if you aren’t happy with needing to not breastfeed? This assumes that breastfeeding is most often some awful thing to be tolerated. Like there’s never going to be some situation where you love it and need to not do it. It’s almost the flip side of every baby deserves breast milk (self flagellation ahoy!)
Breast milk is right for every baby/every baby deserves breast milk.
Just no. First off there are babies intolerant to proteins in mother’s milk. And it’s never worth it to compromise the mother’s health or sanity completely. A little bit, ok, because any baby can be demanding and deprive you of sleep, but when it’s a question of continuing to live or being able to care properly for your baby, then no, it’s not worth it. I also strongly dislike this one as it implies that all the mother is for is for the baby. Mothers are people too. Since when did lactivism supersede feminism?
Formula should be prescription only
Ok. You think that is going to improve breastfeeding care? No. It’s going to punish women for needing to formula feed. I wish everyone wanted to breastfeed and was able to. I do, but I don’t want to punish anyone for not doing it.
You did so well to get so far, most women would have given up.
This drives me up the wall for so many reasons. Foremost is that I could easily have been one of those ‘other women’. I don’t want to make those who did not meet their goals feel any worse if I can help it. How do those women that did ‘give up’ (more like give in) feel when someone says that near them or even to them? It must be like a million tiny slaps in the face. I wince when I encounter it. It’s a guilt inducing phrase and a backhanded compliment all in one. Backhanded because I most often see it applied to women who have been struggling for months and are stopping because things are not working and it’s impacting their life and mental well being too much. Hey, maybe it’s what they need to hear and they are relieved at stopping, but then again, maybe they are not happy with stopping but don’t see any way to make it work. This phrase also assumes that the end goal of breastfeeding is how long can you go, not getting babies fed and not being miserable about it.
I’m strong on breastfeeding because I care about babies.
Those who say this apparently want to promote the emotional wreckage of mothers in favor of helping babies. I’m sure most mothers care more about their babies than you do. You’ve just made her feel like she doesn’t because of breastfeeding. Good job! [sarcasm] Besides, the tactics that often go along with this one (I’m only this way about breastfeeding because I care about babies) are another one of those tactics aimed at the whole of breastfeeding failure or success being on the mother’s shoulders. Nothing about outside support, having issues recognized or corrected or anything else. Those who spout variations of this are pretty much like walking breast is best posters. All why you should and no support or recognition of issues.